Two years ago, we thought strong global growth would be a key prop for an otherwise-weak US economy and earnings. That story has played out in spades: Net exports accounted for all but 30 basis points of the 1.8% growth in output over the past year, and measured in the National Income and Product Accounts, earnings would have declined by 9.4% but for the 21% gain in overseas results.
Now, however, the party’s over. Spillovers from the US slowdown, high inflation, tighter monetary policies, and more cautious lenders are promoting slower global growth. Although the recent decline in energy prices will help slightly, economic activity is fading in many parts of the globe. As a result, we expect global growth to slow from 4.1% this year to 3.6% next year. With headwinds still hobbling domestic demand and earnings, we think this new weakness will trigger outright recession for the US economy and a bust in corporate profits.
The evidence for the global slowdown is mounting. While there are some exceptions, there’s no mistaking the slowing growth in Asia, Europe, and Latin America. In general, because Asian central banks haven’t tightened aggressively, the process of deceleration will unfold slowly. In Japan, faltering production and labor markets point to incipient recession, and we now expect a 20% decline in corporate profits through F3Q09. Economies like India, hard hit by rising inflation and tighter monetary policy, are decelerating, and growth in China is slowing gradually. That has promoted a shift in the stance of Chinese economic policies from fighting inflation to promoting growth. Reduced energy subsidies in many Asian economies are boosting consumer prices for refined products even as crude prices have fallen, and that is also hurting growth. The fallout is spreading to some hitherto-strong Asian economies: Economic activity in New Zealand contracted in the first quarter, and in Australia retail sales volumes have fallen for two consecutive quarters. According to Asian strategist Mal Wood, consensus year-on-year earnings estimates in Asia-Pacific ex-Japan for 2008 fell 300 bp last month to 3.9%, down from 9.2% at the end of 2007. For MSCI China, Jerry Lou notes that consensus 2008 earning growth has slipped to 15.4% in July from 22.1% in January. In India, Ridham Desai observes that second-quarter earnings rose by only 6% from a year ago — the slowest pace in four years.
In Europe, slipping export growth and rising energy prices have combined to undermine business confidence even in resilient Germany, while the smaller economies of Denmark, Spain and Ireland flirt with recession. Surveys suggest that demand expectations are slipping, and some businesses are reporting that inventories are excessive, setting the stage for a classic cyclical downshift in production. Earnings weakness now seems likely to extend into 2009.
In Latin America, until recently, high commodity prices continued to support domestic income and relatively solid growth. As a result, Latin central banks could afford to tighten aggressively. However, even in Latin America we see growth slowing; for example, we believe growth in Brazil will slow to a below-consensus 3.0% in 2009, partly reflecting further tightening in monetary policy this year. Overall growth is slowing in Mexico and manufacturing output is weakening. Softer commodity prices also put growth at risk in Venezuela and Columbia. In Canada, reflecting a strong currency and weakness in motor vehicles, GDP has been flat since January.
Modest benefit from lower oil prices. If sustained, our team expects that the recent $20/bbl drop in oil prices will lessen both inflation and growth concerns in many economies. GDP effects range from as little as 0.3% in Brazil to 1% or more in many Asian economies, where reduced energy subsidies will be needed. In China’s case, for example, Qing Wang thinks the authorities will only need to raise domestic prices by 25-30% instead of 50-60% to bring them to international levels. Of course, crude prices only stayed above $125/bbl for about 5-6 weeks − not really long enough to have a significant further impact on inflation and output.
Slower global growth will hobble US exports and overseas earnings. We think global growth has been by far the strongest factor supporting the boom in US exports and overseas earnings, so the coming global slowdown will likely reverse this strength. We disagree with those who attribute the upturn in US net exports primarily to the dollar’s long slide. To be sure, the dollar’s decline has played a significant role both in making US exports more attractive and in luring production to the US to substitute for imports. For example, the 13.9% appreciation of the euro against the dollar over the past year has probably added a few percentage points to affiliates’ earnings when translated into dollars. If the dollar’s decline were the main story, exports and overseas profits might continue to grow strongly, especially if the dollar resumed its slide.
But we think global growth far outweighs the currency effect. Three factors matter in that regard. First, in a globalized world companies price to local markets, so the “pass-through” from exchange-rate changes to US import prices and to the prices of US exports in overseas markets is much less than 100%. For example, in the past three years, dollar-denominated prices for US exports of consumer and capital goods excluding IT products rose by 6.6% and 9.8%, respectively. But in Europe, prices of imported consumer and capital goods from outside the EU have risen by just 3% and fallen by 6%, respectively. On the other side of the ledger, since their trough five years ago, imported US consumer and capital goods excluding IT products have risen by just 7.2% and 12.5%, respectively. Global supply chains reinforce that tendency, because the import content of goods from abroad may actually be only 40-70%. Thus, the renminbi’s 20% appreciation since 2005 has not been passed through to the prices of US imports from China.
Second, most empirical estimates put the sensitivity of exports and imports to relative price changes at less than one, while their sensitivity to demand or output is one or, in the case of imports, more than one. Finally, the idea that “translation” effects of exchange rate changes on earnings are 1:1 is a myth. That’s because Corporate America doesn’t allow the currency chips to fall where they may; pricing to local markets is facilitated by hedging currency risks with either futures or options. In addition, just as at home, the effects of slower growth on earnings abroad will be magnified by declining operating leverage.
We expect a mild US recession, as the combination of slower growth abroad and still-powerful headwinds at home is a one-two punch for a fragile US economy. Four domestic factors will weigh on the economy over the next few quarters: Despite recent stability in home sales and new legislation helping homeowners and the GSEs, the housing downturn isn’t over. The one-time boost from tax rebates will soon end and payback is coming. Consumers still face falling home prices, slipping jobs and incomes, tighter lending standards, and little relief from higher energy quotes. And businesses face falling operating rates, declining cash flow, and tougher borrowing conditions that will hobble capital spending.
Implications for US equity markets and US policy makers. US earnings are likely to decline by more than analysts expect – and more than is priced into equity markets. For example, we estimate that a 10 percentage-point drop in overseas earnings will trim 350 bp from overall US earnings growth. In my view, earnings disappointments will continue to pressure stock prices to some degree.
Despite slower growth, market Read the rest of this entry »
Sphere: Related Content

Recent Comments